All-Time CIAC Playoff Record
| Year | Result | Game |
| 2011 | Ansonia 38 Ledyard 0 | Class M Championship |
| 2011 | Ansonia 48 Berlin 14 | Class M Semifinal |
| 2011 | Ansonia 35 Bethel 6 | Class M Quarterfinal |
| 2010 | St. Joseph 49 Ansonia 28 | Class S Runner-up |
| 2010 | Ansonia 46 Montville 15 | Class S Semifinal |
| 2010 | Ansonia 47 Hyde 26 | Class S Quarterfinal |
| 2009 | NW Catholic 24 Ansonia 0 | Class S Semifinal |
| 2008 | Cromwell 14 Ansonia 12 | Class S Runner-up |
| 2008 | Ansonia 28 North Branford 0 | Class S Semifinal |
| 2007 | Ansonia 35 New London 0 | Class S Championship |
| 2007 | Ansonia 25 NW Catholic 7 | Class S Semifinal |
| 2006 | Ansonia 34 Bloomfield 14 | Class S Championship |
| 2006 | Ansonia 47 North Branford 14 | Class S Semifinal |
| 2004 | Cromwell 27 Ansonia 19 | Class S Playoff |
| 2003 | Ansonia 55 Cromwell 0 | Class S Championship |
| 2003 | Ansonia 67 Hyde 14 | Class S Playoff |
| 2002 | Ansonia 44 ND Fairfield 14 | Class S Championship |
| 2002 | Ansonia 39 Immaculate 7 | Class S Playoff |
| 2001 | North Branford 21 Ansonia 20 | Class S Playoff |
| 2000 | Griswold 7 Ansonia 6 | Class S Playoff |
| 1999 | Bloomfield 56 Ansonia 0 | Class S Runner-up |
| 1999 | Ansonia 35 Tolland 22 | Class S Playoff |
| 1998 | Bloomfield 40 Ansonia 7 | Class S Runner-up |
| 1998 | Ansonia 45 Putnam 21 | Class S Playoff |
| 1997 | Darien 23 Ansonia 6 | Class S Playoff |
| 1996 | Darien 31 Ansonia 20 | Class S Playoff |
| 1995 | Ansonia 7 Bloomfield 0 | Class S Championship |
| 1995 | Ansonia 16 Sheehan 6 | Class S Playoff |
| 1994 | Ansonia 54 Bloomfield 14 | Class SS Championship |
| 1992 | New London 21 Ansonia 19 | Class S Runner-up |
| 1991 | New London 34 Ansonia 18 | Class S Runner-up |
| 1989 | Ansonia 44 Weston 0 | Class S Championship |
| 1988 | Ansonia 20 New London 15 | Class S Championship |
| 1987 | Ansonia 28 New London 27 | Class S Championship |
| 1984 | Ansonia 56 Putnam 6 | Class S Championship |
| 1983 | Ansonia 32 Stamford Catholic 0 | Class S Championship |
| 1982 | Ansonia 14 Derby 0 | Class S Championship |
| 1981 | Ansonia 23 Wilson 6 | Class SII Championship |
| 1980 | Newington 24 Ansonia 14 | Class L Runner-up |
| 1979 | Ansonia 28 Seymour 14 | Class M Championship |
| 1978 | Amity 35 Ansonia 22 | Class L Runner-up |
| 1977 | Ansonia 20 Stamford Catholic 7 | Class S Championship |
| 1976 | Ansonia 6 Derby 0 | Class S Championship |
Playdown games: 13-5-0
Title Games: 17-8-0
Overall Playoff: 30-13
